BEREA, Ohio—Brady Quinn’s opportunity came and went in a hurry. He waited his whole life to make the NFL and then 1 1/2 years more for his first start for the Cleveland Browns.

And then, it was gone—a three-and-out more painful than any before.

Quinn’s season ended on Wednesday after just three starts, done in by a broken right index finger that he tried to play with last week and may now require surgery.

Given the options of resting or an operation last week, Quinn could have sat out Sunday’s game against Houston. But the second-year QB chose to play and di...

Log-In to view full story or view our Registration Guide.