FOREMAN, Ark.—It’s difficult to get a motel reservation in and around Fayetteville this time of year—unless you’re from Foreman.

Considering the Lady Gators’ softball history, their fans probably book their rooms a year in advance, and there’s little doubt they will be at Lady’Back Field en masse Saturday when Foreman’s girls shoot for their third consecutive Class 2A title against fellow 7-2A West conference member Dierks.

Saturday’s 4 p.m. title game will actually mark Foreman’s fourth straight appearance in Fayetteville. Their only loss was a 2-1, extra-inning decisi...