Bowie County jury sentences man to life in prison for fatally shooting 16-year-old

Demarius Taylor
Demarius Taylor

NEW BOSTON, Texas -A Bowie County jury sentenced a man to life in prison Thursday for shooting a 16-year-old boy in front of his family on a residential street in Texarkana last year.

Demarius Dejuan Taylor, 21, was found guilty of murder in the March 31, 2020, death of Notoryous Crabtree by a Bowie County jury after less than an hour of deliberations Thursday morning. Thursday afternoon the six men and six women tasked with deciding Taylor's fate imposed the maximum punishment with 202nd District Judge John Tidwell presiding.

Witnesses testified that the events leading to the tragic death of Notoryous had nothing to do with him and began earlier in the day in Texarkana, Arkansas, when Demarius Taylor's sister, Bosnia Taylor, 22, was involved in a physical altercation with a group of girls and women on Ash Street.

A 15-year-old cousin of Notoryous' had been present at the earlier skirmish on Ash. Bosnia Taylor testified that she believed she had been struck by a man during the "girl fight" and enlisted the aid of her brother. That night, Bosnia Taylor, Demarius Taylor and a group of about eight men traveled in two SUVs to Meadowbrook Lane where Notoryous' 15-year-old cousin lived with her family.

photo

News-Times/Quentin Winstine El Dorado's defense gang tackles Little Rock Hall's Kelvin Williams on a play for lost yardage. Dalton Gosvenor (50), Mon-tre Marshall (43), Zach McGhee (71) and Johnathan Hall led the charge on the play. The Wildcats shut out the Warriors 29-0 Friday night at Memorial Stadium.

Notoryous, his parents and siblings were at the Meadowbrook home visiting along with other members of the Crabtree's extended family when the Taylors and their friends arrived. While Notoryous' uncle, Ralph Crabtree, and his father, Donald Crabtree, did their best to keep things peaceful and encourage an end to the situation, there was some fighting on the street.

Witnesses testified and video surveillance from a nearby elementary school showed that the people in the SUVs were on Meadowbrook for less than five minutes total. Donald Crabtree testified that nobody was fighting or threatening anyone when Demarius Taylor pointed a handgun toward him where he stood next to Notoryous.

A single shot rang out and Notorious collapsed onto the pavement.

Donald Crabtree cradled his son in his arms as he took his last breath and a number of family members, including young children, witnessed the horror.

"I watched my son be shot, be taken," testified Notoryous' mother, Latorya Eddings Crabtree. "To see him drown in his own blood. You just don't know."

As Latorya Crabtree stepped off the witness stand, she couldn't hold back her tears. The sound of her sobbing faded as the door of the courtroom closed behind her.

Prosecutors pointed to testimony from Texarkana Texas Crime Scene Analyst Spencer Price who testified during the punishment phase of the trial Thursday that Demarius Taylor was arrested in California in August 2019 in possession of a loaded firearm. Arkansas Probation and Parole Officer Tina Washington testified that Demarius Taylor admitted he'd gotten the gun from a family member in Arkansas and driven with it to California.

Howard County Sheriff's Deputy Justin Garner testified that he and a recruit officer arrested Demarius Taylor in October 2019 with a loaded 9 mm handgun, which had been reported stolen in Oklahoma. Garner said that Demarius Taylor told him that "if I'd been by myself that night that pistol would have come out the window."

First Assistant District Attorney Kelley Crisp and Assistant District Attorney Lauren Richards asked the jury to sentence Demarius Taylor to life.

"We should have been celebrating Notoryous' birthday last week. Instead we're looking at his autopsy photos," Richards said. "Tell Demarius Taylor what juries in Bowie County think of someone who murders children in the middle of the street for no reason. This was senseless."

Texarkana lawyer David James asked the jury to consider a term of years, not life.

Crisp argued that Demarius Taylor's conduct puts the public at risk and emphasized the need for justice for the family Notorious left behind.

"The evidence is that this man is driving around with guns, has homicidal thoughts, threatens people and clearly has no regard for human life," Crisp argued before turning her thoughts to the victim's family. "Don't you know this has been the longest three days of their lives? Let's send the Crabtrees home with a little less grief tonight."

Charges remain pending against Bosnia Taylor in the case. She is being held in the Bowie County jail with bail set at $1 million.

Upcoming Events